Smedia's judges comments

We had an excellent panel of top journalists and broadcasters judging this year's oxygen.ie National Student Media Awards. We asked each judge to share their expertise by filling in a sheet giving their impressions and thoughts on the shortlisted entries. And now we're sharing these with you the entrants...

Which winner showed "maturity and wisdom"? Who "pulled at the heart strings of the viewer and brings real emotion to the story?" In which category were all of the entries "unoriginal, po-faced, unimaginative and lacking individuality?" Which judge wants a "radical" shake up in Irish student media?